Anabelle Colaco
12 Jul 2026, 10:25 GMT+10
MENLO PARK, California: Meta's new artificial intelligence image detection tool struggles to identify some of its own AI-generated images after they are cropped, highlighting the challenges of verifying manipulated content as AI-generated images become more widespread.
The company previewed the tool this week alongside the launch of its new image-generation model, Muse Image, saying it can identify AI-generated images using an invisible watermarking system called Content Seal.
However, testing by Reuters found the tool successfully identified all 40 original images generated with Muse Image but failed to verify 55 percent of the same images after they were cropped to roughly one-third to one-half of their original size.
According to Meta, Content Seal is embedded in every image produced by Muse Image and is designed to remain intact even after common edits, allowing users to verify whether the company's AI models created an image.
Responding to Reuters' findings, Meta noted that the detection tool remains a preview. The company said the watermark is intended to survive common edits but acknowledged the signal may be lost if an image is heavily cropped.
The results underscore the broader challenge of authenticating AI-generated content after it has been modified, a limitation that could complicate efforts to identify deepfakes during a busy election year that includes the U.S. midterm elections.
Google and OpenAI have also cautioned that their own AI image detection tools are not foolproof against image-altering techniques.
In March, Meta's Oversight Board, an independent body that issues binding decisions and recommendations on content moderation across the company's platforms, urged the company to do more to address the "proliferation of deceptive AI-generated content" and invest in stronger detection tools.
Siwei Lyu, a computer science professor at the State University of New York at Buffalo who researches AI image forensics, said he had not evaluated Meta's system but noted that watermark-based detection has inherent limitations.
"Watermark-based methods can be highly effective when the watermark remains intact, but any modification that removes or weakens the embedded signal, such as cropping, resizing, heavy compression, or editing, may reduce their effectiveness, depending on how the watermark is designed," Lyu said.
Sarah Barrington, an AI researcher and Ph.D. candidate at the UC Berkeley School of Information, said watermarking remained a promising approach despite its shortcomings.
"Like many preventive cybersecurity or physical security measures, it may not be fully watertight, but even if we catch only 90 percent of cases, that's still a great leap from 0," she said.
Get a daily dose of Milwaukee Sun news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Milwaukee Sun.
More InformationMOSCOW, Russia: One of Russia's most influential independent newspapers, Novaya Gazeta, has closed its operations and vacated its central...
WELLINGTON, New Zealand: New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon is likely to remain in power after the weekend election, but...
LONDON, U.K.: British comedian and actor Russell Brand has been sentenced to 10 years and six months in prison after being found guilty...
WARSAW, Poland: The gunman who allegedly killed six people and wounded 16 more in a mass shooting in the main square of the Polish...
CHICAGO, Illinois: Two experimental heart disease treatments developed by Novartis and Novo Nordisk failed to prevent major cardiovascular...
ASUNCION, Paraguay: Paraguay plunged deeper into political turmoil late on November 6 as Pedro Alliana took office as president after...
(Photo credit: Mark Hoffman) Austin Rapp had 15 points and Braeden Carrington and Owen Foxwell added 14 apiece as Wisconsin took...
(Photo credit: Wendell Cruz) Karl-Anthony Towns continued his season-opening streak of double-doubles Tuesday night and the host...
(Photo credit: Andrew Nelles) Kirk Cousins is headed back to the Minnesota Vikings in a trade with the Las Vegas Raiders announced...
(Photo credit: Benny Sieu) Pat Murphy of the World Series champion Milwaukee Brewers made MLB history with his third consecutive...
(Photo credit: Jeffrey Becker) Kirk Cousins is headed back to the Minnesota Vikings in a deadline trade with the Las Vegas Raiders...
(Photo credit: Mark Hoffman) Wisconsin is looking for more offensive consistency from its revamped roster when it hosts Fairfield...
