Mohan Sinha
08 Aug 2026, 13:52 GMT+10
DUBLIN, Ireland: Supermac's has suffered another defeat in its prolonged trademark dispute with McDonald's, after the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) determined that the Irish chain's branding is too similar to the globally recognized "Big Mac" trademark.
The decision means that Supermac's cannot secure EU-wide trademark protection for its name, although it can continue operating under that name within Ireland.
The ruling followed an appeal by Supermac's against an earlier EUIPO decision that sided with McDonald's International Property Company. That earlier finding concluded that registering "Supermac's" as an EU trademark for fast-food services could cause consumer confusion.
The dispute dates back to 2016, when Supermac's applied to register its name across the European Union. McDonald's opposed the move, citing its long-standing "Big Mac" trademark, which has been registered for meat sandwiches since 1998 and has built significant global recognition.
Supermac's argued during the appeal that the two brands had coexisted in Ireland for roughly four decades without evidence of public confusion. The company also challenged the earlier EUIPO assessment, saying it acknowledged only low to average similarities between the brands yet still concluded there was a risk of confusion, a conclusion Supermac's maintained was inconsistent.
"There's no reasonable likelihood that the relevant public would mistake a Supermac's restaurant for a Big Mac burger," the company argued in its submission.
The Irish chain further contended that accepting the ruling would imply customers might visit one of its restaurants expecting to purchase a McDonald's product, despite the latter's strong global identity.
McDonald's countered that the situation in Ireland was not decisive, emphasizing that the case concerned the broader European Union, where "Big Mac" is widely recognized. The company maintained that consumers might not clearly distinguish between a product name and a restaurant brand, particularly given the strength of its flagship item.
It described the "Big Mac" as an iconic product closely tied to its identity for more than 40 years, arguing that it carries a high degree of distinctiveness and reputation. McDonald's also asserted that the distinction between product branding and restaurant naming can be blurred in consumers' perceptions.
In its assessment, the EUIPO board of appeal found that the goods and services in question—fast food products and restaurant services—were related and aimed at the same audience, making them at least somewhat similar. It also concluded that the two names shared some limited visual and phonetic similarities and a more notable conceptual overlap.
The board highlighted the strong recognition of the "Big Mac" trademark across the EU, particularly among fast-food consumers, and said its established reputation increases the likelihood of confusion. It emphasized that stronger trademarks are entitled to broader protection under EU law.
Ultimately, the board determined that the similarities between the two brands, combined with the high distinctiveness of "Big Mac," meant confusion could not be ruled out. It suggested that consumers might interpret "Supermac's" as a related or derivative brand.
The ruling also clarified that trademark assessments must be based on how consumers perceive the marks, rather than the marketing intentions of the companies involved. Additionally, it stated that evidence of coexistence in a single country, such as Ireland, was insufficient when evaluating rights that apply across the entire EU.
This latest setback comes despite a previous legal victory for Supermac's in 2024, when the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled to limit McDonald's use of the "Big Mac" trademark in certain areas, including restaurant services and poultry products.
Get a daily dose of Milwaukee Sun news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Milwaukee Sun.
More InformationKYIV, Ukraine: A wave of Russian missiles and drones hit Kyiv and around a dozen Ukrainian regions on the night of October 6, killing...
JERUSALEM, Israel: Three years after Hamas attacked Israel on October 7, 2023, Israelis marked the anniversary with vigils and memorial...
PARIS, France: French high school students blocked schools again on October 6 as a nationwide protest movement demanding more resources...
TEL AVIV, Israel: Three years after Hamas' October 7 attack, at least nine Israelis from families directly affected by the assault...
SYDNEY, Australia: Australia's conservative opposition coalition has proposed major immigration cuts, targeting temporary and humanitarian...
RIYADH, Saudi Arabia: Saudi-backed Yemeni government forces have taken effective control of the Bab el-Mandeb Strait, a key route for...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: A sharp slowdown in U.S. hiring in September and hefty downward revisions to previous months pushed the prospect...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: U.S. consumer spending surged in August while inflation rose less than economists expected, a combination that could...
(Photo credit: David Frerker) After an impressive postseason, San Diego Padres right-hander Michael King faces a decision that could...
(Photo credit: Matt Marton) Chicago Bears running back D'Andre Swift was a limited participant in practice Thursday, one day after...
(Photo credit: Stephen Lew) Three weeks ago, fans and media members alike scoffed at the fact that the national audience would be...
(Photo credit: Wendell Cruz) Rookie Victor Mesa Jr. belted a tiebreaking two-run homer in the sixth inning and the Tampa Bay Rays...
