Sam Raimi's masterful thriller A Simple Plan, which was based on the first novel by Scott B. Smith, is built on a great "what if" scenario: What if you and a couple of friends were walking through the woods and found $4 million? Would you turn it in to the police? Or, would you and your friends keep the money and split it amongst yourselves? It looks like the money is from drug dealers ... no one saw you in the woods ... nothing could go wrong, right?

In A Simple Plan, this scenario is acted out in a tightly coiled, tragic morality play in the cold, snow-washed backdrop of northern Minnesota in the dead of winter. The film is deceptively simple in conception, yet tense, exhilarating, and emotionally draining in execution. It has deep moral roots that go to the heart of the great paradoxical nature of the human condition: On the one side, trust and honesty; on the other side, duplicity, greed, and violence. The film's impact is rooted in how these conflicting elements of human nature co-exist in all of us, and its most pertinent—and frightening—insight (one that Alfred Hitchcock explored again and again) is how it takes only the slightest push to tip the scales. Bill Paxton, who had established himself with a series of supporting roles in hit films like Tombstone (1993), Apollo 13 (1995), and Titanic (1997), as well as the lead in Twister (1998), stars as Hank Mitchell, a small-town mill worker who is generally happy in life. He is, as far as we know, honest and upright and makes a good living, and he has a loving wife named Sarah (Bridget Fonda) who is about to bear their first child. His exterior is everything that is decent and principled in humanity; but, as we will soon see, this is but a thin, socially guided veneer.

One day, Hank, his simple-minded older brother Jacob (Billy Bob Thornton), and Jacob's drunkard friend Lou (Brent Briscoe) are walking in the woods when they happen upon a downed plane with a dead body in the pilot's seat and a large duffel bag filled with $4.4 million in cash. Hank immediately wants to turn it over to the authorities ("Well, it's a police problem now," he announces, as if there were no other alternatives). His initial reaction to the situation is to do what seems right and lawful. After all, it is not their money, and to take it would be stealing. However, Jacob and Lou easily—a bit too easily—convince him that they should hide it from the authorities and split it amongst themselves. It looks like it is drug dealer money, so it is not really stealing, and with it, they could buy all those dreams that once seemed so far out of reach ("It's the American Dream in a bag," Lou says). Although Hank is reluctant (as he should be), he agrees, but only if he is allowed to hold onto the money for several months until the plane is discovered and they are sure no one is looking for the cash. This—the "simple plan" of the title—appears straightforward and logical. Hank, Jacob, and Lou are being cautious, taking their time, and making plans to ensure they will not be caught. However, as the days tick by, a cascading series of events cause their simple plan to unspool, and by the time all is said and done, there are several dead bodies to account for.

Elegantly paced and narratively taut, A Simple Plan treads a careful line between escapist thrills and a troubling exploration of modern morality and the evil that lurks in all of us (again, Hitchcock comparisons are all too appropriate). In his previous films, the tongue-in-cheek horror comedy The Evil Dead (1981) and its two sequels and the comic-book-inspired Darkman (1990), director Sam Raimi had already demonstrated that he had gobs of cinematic talent, but A Simple Plan showed that he also had discipline and a conscience. Not once does he go for the easy scene or the quick pay-off; everything is carefully built on earlier scenes, which steadily build until the narrative crescendo when all the threads come together in a sequence that is logical, believable, appropriate, and utterly heart-rending.

Paxton's Hank is an imminently likable character of increasingly dark moral shading; the brilliance of his performance is that there is no moment when you feel that Hank has finally gone too far because, in convincing himself that everything is justified, he tempts us to do the same, which blurs our moral perception. He is the seemingly ordinary man caught in extraordinary circumstances, one who makes a number of fatal mistakes and commits horrible acts, yet remains terribly sympathetic. The question of whether his moral compass is twisted by the film's events or whether it was twisted all along and just waiting for a situation to engage it remains tantalizingly vague, leaving the character in a swirl of gray.

However, it is Billy Bob Thornton's performance as Jacob that is arguably the key to the film's moral structure (while he certainly deserved the Best Supporting Actor Oscar for which he was nominated, the award went to James Coburn for his role in Paul Schrader's Affliction). Thornton's portrayal of a man whom most would write off as "a loser" is subtle and convincing, profound in the nuance and detail that he invests in the constant conflict between Jacob's wounded sense of self and naïve desires to heal his past. Although he is initially depicted as Hank's inferior (in community stature, finances, education), he eventually proves to be the man of greater moral clarity; he has a true conscience that, unlike Hank's, grows with each of the film's violent plot turns, rather than shrinks. At one point late in the film, Jacob asks Hank in a quiet, sad voice, "Do you ever feel evil?," and after a long pause says, "I do." (Tellingly, Hank never answers.) It is an emotionally gripping scene because Thornton makes palpable his character's dawning awareness of the horror of his own actions and how they can't be justified by even his most simple, understandable desires to be loved and accepted. He is the perennial outsider, tragically desperate for something that can never be his.

Which brings us to Bridget Fonda. Although it initially appears that her Sarah will descend to the narrative margins as the stock "good wife" character, perhaps turning up from time to time with her soft eyes to offer counterpoint to Hank's actions, she turns out to be the film's shrewdest, most diabolical figure. Like Lady Macbeth, she gets drawn into her husband's malevolence with astounding ease despite her early attempts to stay lawful, and then proceeds to surpass him in conniving and murderous intentions. Although she initially suggests a character of firm moral grounding (she's a librarian and new mother!), she ultimately reveals a deep, festering desire for a material life, one that she chillingly uses to slice at Hank's late-stage attempt to abandon their efforts.

The malevolence in A Simple Plan could take place anywhere, although the rural setting in the dead of winter makes it feel all the more bone-chilling. The narrative is deeply rooted in the age-old struggle of good and evil, and it shows clearly the painful truth that not all evil is punished in the conventional, law-abiding sense. The plan may have been simple, but the consequences are complex and troubling, even as it suggests that the ultimate price of duplicity and greed is far worse than a jail cell.

Copyright © 2026 James Kendrick

Thoughts? E-mail James Kendrick

All images copyright © Arrow Video